Skip to content

FREE Custom Pencil Box when you spend $50+, add to cart & it’s automatically free!

School Supplies
- Annotation Kits
- Pens + Writing
  
  Pens
  Pencils
  Mechanical Pencils
  Colored Pencils
  Brushes
- Highlighters + Markers
  
  Highlighters
  Markers
  Gel Crayons
  Dry Erase Markers
- Pouches + Organization
  
  Pencil Pouches + Boxes
  Binders
  Folder Pack
  Sheet Protectors
- Stationary
  
  Sticky Notes
  Paper
  Index Cards
  Notebooks and Planners
- Classroom Essentials
  
  Erasers
  Bookmarks + Clips
  Geometry Sets
  Rulers
  Sharpeners
  Lead Refills
  Staples
  Calculators
  Glue
  Scissors
  Craft Sticks
Bible Supplies
- Bible Journaling Kits
- Bible Pens
  
  Gel Pens
  Black Ink
  Color Ink
  Felt Tip Pens
  Aesthetic Pens
- Bible Highlighters
  
  Aesthetic Highlighters
  Gel Highlighters
  Pen + Highlighter Kits
- Journaling Accessories
  
  Sticky Notes
  Bible Stickers
  Bible Cases and Pouches
  Bible Stencil
  Washi Tape
- Bible Tabs
Bibles + Journals
- Journaling Bibles
  
  ESV Translation
  NLT Translation
  KJV Translation
- Prayer Journals
- Christian Planners

School Supplies
- Annotation Kits
- Pens + Writing
  
  Pens
  Pencils
  Mechanical Pencils
  Colored Pencils
  Brushes
- Highlighters + Markers
  
  Highlighters
  Markers
  Gel Crayons
  Dry Erase Markers
- Pouches + Organization
  
  Pencil Pouches + Boxes
  Binders
  Folder Pack
  Sheet Protectors
- Stationary
  
  Sticky Notes
  Paper
  Index Cards
  Notebooks and Planners
- Classroom Essentials
  
  Erasers
  Bookmarks + Clips
  Geometry Sets
  Rulers
  Sharpeners
  Lead Refills
  Staples
  Calculators
  Glue
  Scissors
  Craft Sticks
Bible Supplies
- Bible Journaling Kits
- Bible Pens
  
  Gel Pens
  Black Ink
  Color Ink
  Felt Tip Pens
  Aesthetic Pens
- Bible Highlighters
  
  Aesthetic Highlighters
  Gel Highlighters
  Pen + Highlighter Kits
- Journaling Accessories
  
  Sticky Notes
  Bible Stickers
  Bible Cases and Pouches
  Bible Stencil
  Washi Tape
- Bible Tabs
Bibles + Journals
- Journaling Bibles
  
  ESV Translation
  NLT Translation
  KJV Translation
- Prayer Journals
- Christian Planners

Search

Cart

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: Stocking Stuffers

2025 Holiday Gift Guide

Sort by:

137 products

Filter:

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (137 products)
Out of stock (7 products)

Price

The highest price is $15.99

$

From

To

More filters (0) Match all

More filters

0.3mm Mechanical Pencil (1 product)
0.5mm Mechanical Pencil (1 product)
0.9mm Mechanical Pencil (1 product)
2mm Mechanical Pencil (1 product)
.7mm Mechanical Pencil (1 product)
annotation (4 products)
Architects (4 products)
Architecture (7 products)
Art Supplies (6 products)
Bible (29 products)
Bible Cases (1 product)
Bible Highlighters (3 products)
Bible Journaling Kits (1 product)
Bible Tabs (4 products)
Bible. School (1 product)
Black Ink (7 products)
Calculators (9 products)
Chisel Tip Highlighters (6 products)
Colored Ink (2 products)
Donation (1 product)
Dry Erase Markers (3 products)
Erasers (9 products)
Felt Tip Pens (2 products)
Fine Liner (1 product)
Gel Highlighters (7 products)
Gel Pens (5 products)
Graph Paper (5 products)
Highlighter (3 products)
Highlighters (14 products)
House (1 product)
Journal (2 products)
Kids School (17 products)
Marker Pens (1 product)
Markers (10 products)
Math (7 products)
MCF (38 products)
Mechanical Pencils (2 products)
Mr. Pen New Products 2024 (12 products)
Mr. Pen New Products 2025 (8 products)
New (8 products)
Packing tape (2 products)
Paper & Sticky notes (7 products)
Pen + Highlighter Pack (3 products)
Pen Holders (1 product)
Pencil Cases (2 products)
Pencil Erasers (9 products)
Pencil Pouches (4 products)
Pens (15 products)
Pet Supplies (1 product)
Planner (1 product)
Plastic Rulers (6 products)
Product (8 products)
Rulers (7 products)
School (36 products)
School & Office (32 products)
Scissors (4 products)
Shop (8 products)
Stickers (1 product)
Sticky Notes (18 products)
Tools (1 product)
Transparent Sticky Notes (8 products)
Washi Tapes (3 products)

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

137 products

Availability

In stock (137 products)
Out of stock (7 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $15.99

$

From

$

To

Clear

More filters

0.3mm Mechanical Pencil (1 products)
0.5mm Mechanical Pencil (1 products)
0.9mm Mechanical Pencil (1 products)
2mm Mechanical Pencil (1 products)
.7mm Mechanical Pencil (1 products)
annotation (4 products)
Architects (4 products)
Architecture (7 products)
Art Supplies (6 products)
Bible (29 products)
Bible Cases (1 products)
Bible Highlighters (3 products)
Bible Journaling Kits (1 products)
Bible Tabs (4 products)
Bible. School (1 products)
Black Ink (7 products)
Calculators (9 products)
Chisel Tip Highlighters (6 products)
Colored Ink (2 products)
Donation (1 products)
Dry Erase Markers (3 products)
Erasers (9 products)
Felt Tip Pens (2 products)
Fine Liner (1 products)
Gel Highlighters (7 products)
Gel Pens (5 products)
Graph Paper (5 products)
Highlighter (3 products)
Highlighters (14 products)
House (1 products)
Journal (2 products)
Kids School (17 products)
Marker Pens (1 products)
Markers (10 products)
Math (7 products)
MCF (38 products)
Mechanical Pencils (2 products)
Mr. Pen New Products 2024 (12 products)
Mr. Pen New Products 2025 (8 products)
New (8 products)
Packing tape (2 products)
Paper & Sticky notes (7 products)
Pen + Highlighter Pack (3 products)
Pen Holders (1 products)
Pencil Cases (2 products)
Pencil Erasers (9 products)
Pencil Pouches (4 products)
Pens (15 products)
Pet Supplies (1 products)
Planner (1 products)
Plastic Rulers (6 products)
Product (8 products)
Rulers (7 products)
School (36 products)
School & Office (32 products)
Scissors (4 products)
Shop (8 products)
Stickers (1 products)
Sticky Notes (18 products)
Tools (1 products)
Transparent Sticky Notes (8 products)
Washi Tapes (3 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

137 products

Retractable Gel Pens, 6 or 12 Pack, Morandi & Vintage Barrels, Black Ink, Fine Point 0.5mm, Fast Dry

Sale

Retractable Gel Pens, 6 or 12 Pack, Morandi & Vintage Barrels, Black Ink, Fine Point 0.5mm, Fast Dry

Regular price From $8.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price From $8.99
Unit price per

Sale
Aesthetic Highlighters, 16 Pack, Assorted Colors, No-Bleed Ink, Chisel Tip, Cute Bible-Safe Study Supplies

Sale

Aesthetic Highlighters, 16 Pack, Assorted Colors, No-Bleed Ink, Chisel Tip, Cute Bible-Safe Study Supplies

Regular price From $8.99

Regular price ~~$11.99~~ Sale price From $8.99
Unit price per

Sale
Aesthetic Highlighters & Ballpoint Pens, 12 Pack, Black Ink, No-Bleed, Soft Colors, Chisel Tip + Ballpoint Pens, Journaling & Study Set

Sale

Aesthetic Highlighters & Ballpoint Pens, 12 Pack, Black Ink, No-Bleed, Soft Colors, Chisel Tip + Ballpoint Pens, Journaling & Study Set

Regular price From $8.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price From $8.99
Unit price per

Sale
Mr. Pen Bible Reading Tracker Sticker, 5x7 Matte Finish, Color Your Books Visual Milestone for Bible Journaling, Hand Designed

Sale

Mr. Pen Bible Reading Tracker Sticker, 5x7 Matte Finish, Color Your Books Visual Milestone for Bible Journaling, Hand Designed

Regular price From $3.99

Regular price ~~$4.99~~ Sale price From $3.99
Unit price per

Sale
Milena Ciciotti Journals for Prayer, Prayer Journals for Children

Sale

Milena Ciciotti Journals for Prayer, Prayer Journals for Children

Regular price From $8.99

Regular price ~~$17.99~~ Sale price From $8.99
Unit price per

Sale
Retractable Gel Pens, 12 Pack, Cute Design, Colored Ink, Quick-Dry, Fine Point 0.7mm

Sale

Retractable Gel Pens, 12 Pack, Cute Design, Colored Ink, Quick-Dry, Fine Point 0.7mm

Regular price From $8.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price From $8.99
Unit price per

Sale
Retractable Gel Pens, 12 Pack, 0.7mm Fine Point, Fast Dry Ink, Assorted Colors

Sale

Retractable Gel Pens, 12 Pack, 0.7mm Fine Point, Fast Dry Ink, Assorted Colors

Regular price $10.99

Regular price ~~$11.99~~ Sale price $10.99
Unit price per

Sale
Mr. Pen- Bible Highlighters with Color-Coding System, 8 Pack, Soft Pastel Aesthetic Highlighters Assorted Colors

Sold out

Mr. Pen- Bible Highlighters with Color-Coding System, 8 Pack, Soft Pastel Aesthetic Highlighters Assorted Colors

Regular price $5.85

Regular price ~~$7.85~~ Sale price $5.85
Unit price per

Sold out
Metal Mechanical Pencil Set with Lead & Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes: 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 2.0 mm

Sale

Metal Mechanical Pencil Set with Lead & Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes: 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 2.0 mm

Regular price $9.99

Regular price ~~$16.99~~ Sale price $9.99
Unit price per

Sale
Sticky Tabs 3200 Pcs, Colorful Transparent Book Tabs, Page Markers, Index Tabs for Notes & Organizing

Sale

Sticky Tabs 3200 Pcs, Colorful Transparent Book Tabs, Page Markers, Index Tabs for Notes & Organizing

Regular price $10.99

Regular price ~~$12.99~~ Sale price $10.99
Unit price per

Sale
Bible Highlighters & Gel Highlighters, 8 Pack, Assorted Colors, No Bleed

Sale

Bible Highlighters & Gel Highlighters, 8 Pack, Assorted Colors, No Bleed

Regular price $4.99

Regular price ~~$7.99~~ Sale price $4.99
Unit price per

Sale
Bible Study Sticky Notes & Index Tabs, Vintage Colors, Scripture & Note Sheets Set, 225 Pieces

Sale

Bible Study Sticky Notes & Index Tabs, Vintage Colors, Scripture & Note Sheets Set, 225 Pieces

Regular price $6.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price $6.99
Unit price per

Sale

1
2
3
…
12

Over 1 Million Reviews Worldwide

Catagories

School Supplies
Bible Supplies
Bibles + Journals

About

About Us
Shipping
Highlight My Work
Warranty
Contact Us
Selah by Mr. Pen Blog
All Things Mr. Pen Blog
Login to Account

Other

Store Locator
Donation Requests
Retail Application
Bulk Purchase Request
Customized Product Request
Collaboration Requests
Free Gift
Sitemap

Our Mission

Founded by teachers in Louisiana, with the mission to create and equip everyone with tools to enjoy the Bible.

© 2026, Mr. Pen

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.

{"themeColor":"#4c5950","iconColor":"#4c5950","showLogo":true,"topBottomPosition":10,"rightLeftPosition":10,"iconSize":"small","iconCustomSize":64,"position":"bottom-left"}